|
Why Visitors Don't Turn Into Supporters (And How to Fix It)
Hey there,
Quick question: How many people visited your website last month?
Now, how many of them gave you their email?
If that number makes you wince, keep reading.
|
|
|
The Problem Nobody's Talking About
Last week we talked about nonprofits being great at getting attention but terrible at what comes next.
Here's what comes next: Capture.
Right now, people are visiting your site and leaving without a trace. No email. No follow-up. No way to reach them again.
Here's the truth: You can't fundraise from strangers who visited your site once. You fundraise from people you can actually reach.
|
|
|
Why Your Website Isn't Capturing Anyone
|
|
|
Walk through your own site right now. What happens after someone lands on your homepage?
Most nonprofits have:
- Generic "Subscribe to our newsletter" buttons (nobody cares)
- No clear next step (so people just leave)
- No value exchange (why would I give you my email?)
- Hidden signup forms (can't find it = won't sign up)
The fix is stupidly simple:
Give people something worth trading their email for.
❌ "Subscribe for updates"
✅ "Download our 2026 Impact Report"
❌ "Join our mailing list"
✅ "Get the Grant Writing Starter Kit"
❌ "Stay informed"
✅ "Access our exclusive Nonprofit Software Guide"
See the difference?
|
|
|
Speaking of Resources: Grant Opportunities Right Now
Since we're talking about capture and growth, here are grants you should know about:
OpenAI People-First AI Fund |
|
- Amount: $50M total commitment
- Who: U.S. 501(c)(3) organizations
- Sweet spot: $500K to $10M operating budget
- Status: Rolling applications (next wave TBA)
- Why it matters: Unrestricted funding for AI integration
|
Grant Opportunities to Apply By End of May 2026
Pulitzer Center Civil Society Micro-Grants |
|
- Amount: $2,000 - $4,000
- Who Can Apply: Grassroots organizations, civil society organizations, and coalitions in Southeast Asia, Latin America, or Africa
- Duration: 9 months (Mar-Nov)
|
Regional Grants with May 2026 Deadlines: Texas Regional Grants (Deadline: May 15, 2026)
Mary E. Bivins Foundation (Deadline: May 18, 2026)
- Location: 26 northernmost counties of Texas Panhandle
- Focus: Short-term rehabilitation, long-term services for elderly and families
|
|
Stinson Foundation - Catalyst Grant Program
- Focus: Education, health, poverty, human services, children/youth, arts, civic affairs
Amount: Smaller grant awards (specific amounts vary)
Virginia Hobbs Charitable Trust
- Location: North Texas
- Focus: Medical research, children's initiatives, animal welfare, arts and culture
Oliver Dewey Mayor Foundation
- Location: Grayson County, Texas
- Focus: Youth programs, medical programs, education, leadership training, cultural activities
|
|
|
|
Free Resources We're Giving Away |
|
|
Website Capture Audit Template
Self-audit checklist to find where you’re losing visitors.
|
|
Grant Application Tracker
Spreadsheet to manage multiple applications without losing your mind.
|
|
Email Capture Copywriting Guide
Swipe file of high-converting signup copy.
|
|
|
|
Your Action Plan (Pick One)
Don't try to do everything. Pick ONE thing:
Option A (Quick Win): Add one clear call-to-action to your homepage offering something valuable. Do it today.
Option B (Bigger Impact): Book a free 20-minute audit with us. We'll tell you exactly where you're losing people.
Option C (DIY): Use our free audit template and fix it yourself this week.
|
|
|
Quick Poll
| Reply and tell me: What's stopping you from capturing more emails? |
|
|
|
|
|
Talk soon,
The Nonprofit Lab Team
P.S. That grant tracker template? One nonprofit told us it saved them 10+ hours last month. It's free. Grab it.
|
|
|
The Nonprofit Lab - By Quokkaforgood.com
Helping nonprofits grow through funding + marketing systems.
You’re receiving this because you’re building or growing a nonprofit. We share practical strategies on funding, grants, and digital growth.
If you're stuck or need clarity, you can book a free consultation here.
Unsubscribe · Preferences
|
|
|